Key Takeaways
  • Migration Assistant fails for a few common reasons. Connection problems, outdated macOS, firewall settings, or disk errors are the most frequent causes — and most can be resolved without reinstalling the system.
  • Start with the basics before advanced fixes. Update macOS on both Macs, keep them close together and on power, disable VPN and firewall software temporarily, and confirm your cable supports data transfer.
  • Built-in tools can diagnose and fix the issue. Apple Diagnostics checks for hardware problems, Disk Utility First Aid fixes disk errors in Recovery mode, and resetting the SMC resolves low-level hardware issues on Intel Macs.
  • A Time Machine backup is your best fallback. If a direct Mac-to-Mac transfer fails, Migration Assistant can migrate your data from a Time Machine backup instead — just connect the backup disk to your new Mac and follow the prompts.
  • Setapp apps can fill the gaps Migration Assistant leaves. CleanMyMac scans your Mac before migration, Get Backup Pro creates reliable backups beforehand, and Dropshare moves files through cloud storage when cables aren't an option. All are available with Setapp Membership. Try them free for 7 days.

Migration Assistant usually stops working because of a connection issue, outdated macOS, or a disk error on one of your Macs. I've put together nine fixes that cover the most common causes, starting with quick network and cable checks, and working up to recovery mode, SMC reset, and Time Machine migration if needed.

Here's a quick look at all nine fixes. Full instructions for each are below:

The problemThe fix
Migration Assistant not ready to startUpdate macOS, disable VPN
Migration Assistant unable to connectCheck cables and ports
Security software blockingTurn off firewall
"This Mac can't be used to migrate data"Run Apple Diagnostics to check for hardware issues
Need to transfer files without Migration AssistantUse Target Disk Mode (Intel) or Share Disk (Apple silicon)
"Migration Assistant logging out failed"Reinstall macOS via macOS Recovery
Disk errors suspectedStart Mac in Recovery mode and run Disk Utility First Aid
Migration Assistant freezes or loses connectivityReset the SMC (Intel Macs only; restart suffices for Apple silicon)
Direct Mac-to-Mac transfer fails completelyMigrate from a Time Machine backup instead

Or get Dropshare app only from $39.00 USD + tax.

How to fix Migration Assistant not working

Typically, Apple Migration Assistant gets stuck because of a connection, software, or disk issue. Start with the checks below and work your way down.

Fix 1. Check your Mac and network setup before the transfer

Before changing any advanced settings, confirm that both Macs are ready for the transfer:

  1. Install the latest macOS version each Mac supports.
  2. Keep both Macs near each other and connected to power.
  3. If either Mac is running OS X El Capitan or earlier, connect both Macs to the same Wi-Fi network.
  4. Temporarily pause any VPN, firewall, or third-party security software.
  5. Quit open apps on both Macs, as a best practice.

Apple also recommends installing available macOS updates before using Migration Assistant. See Apple’s Migration Assistant guide for the latest requirements.

Now, try migrating again.

Fix 2. Check cable connections

The next thing to do if Migration Assistant is unable to connect is to verify your cable connections.

Check each of the following:

  • Check that the cable supports data transfer and works with both Macs. You can use Ethernet, Thunderbolt, or USB-C where supported.
  • Check the ports and cables for damage.
  • Go to System Settings > Network when using Ethernet. Make sure Ethernet is connected on both Macs.
  • If both Macs are connected to the same router or switch via Ethernet, make sure they are on the same network. If you are using a direct Ethernet cable between the two Macs, macOS will handle the connection automatically; no network configuration is needed.

You can also restart both devices before trying the transfer again.

Or get CleanMyMac as a standalone app from $9.95 USD/mo + tax. No membership needed.

Fix 3. Turn off the firewall on Mac

Security software can prevent file migration. If Migration Assistant is not connecting, temporarily turn off the firewall:

  1. Go to System Settings > Network > Firewall.
  2. Turn off Firewall.
  3. Enter your administrator password or use Touch ID if prompted.
  4. Run Migration Assistant again.
  5. Return to the same settings and turn on Firewall after the transfer.

Firewalls protect your Mac from unauthorized connections, so leave yours off only while troubleshooting.

Before retrying, you can use CleanMyMac to scan your Mac for malware or unusual behavior. CleanMyMac doesn’t replace the firewall, so remember to turn the firewall back on immediately afterward. 

I've used CleanMyMac before major transfers to make sure I'm not carrying malware or junk files over to a new Mac. It takes a few minutes and gives you peace of mind before committing to a full migration.

The Protection scan in CleanMyMac, a Mac cleaning app available on Setapp

Fix 4. Run Apple Diagnostics

If you get the message “This Mac can’t be used to migrate data,” run Apple Diagnostics to check for hardware issues. 

Here’s how to do this:

  1. Disconnect external devices except the keyboard, mouse, display, and Ethernet connection.
  2. Shut down your Mac by choosing Apple menu > Shut Down.
  3. Start Apple Diagnostics using the steps for your processor:
    • On an Apple silicon Mac, press and hold the power button until startup options appear, then release it. Press and hold Command + D.
    • On an Intel Mac, turn it on and immediately press and hold D. If that doesn't work, try pressing and holding Option + D instead.
  4. Choose your language if prompted and follow the on-screen instructions.

Apple Diagnostics automatically runs several hardware tests. When it finishes, it lists any errors it finds. Each issue includes an Apple Diagnostics reference code for further troubleshooting.

Fix 5. Use Target Disk Mode

Target disk mode lets an Intel Mac behave like an external drive. On Apple silicon Macs, the equivalent feature is called Share Disk.

Here’s how to do it:

  1. Connect the two Macs with a Thunderbolt cable.
  2. Start disk sharing on the source Mac:
    • On an Intel Mac, turn it on and immediately press and hold T.
    • On an Apple silicon Mac, press and hold the power button until startup options appear, then release it. Choose Options to enter macOS Recovery, then choose Utilities > Share Disk.
  3. Open Finder on the destination Mac.
  4. Double-click the source Mac's disk in the sidebar.
  5. Copy the files you need to the destination Mac.

This method copies files manually. It doesn’t migrate user accounts, system settings, or apps in the same way as Migration Assistant. Apple provides additional instructions for transferring files with target disk mode.

If you'd rather skip the cables altogether, I recommend Dropshare from Setapp. It brings your cloud storage accounts together in one place, making it easier to move files across your Macs.

Data migration with Dropshare works like this:

  1. Install and open Dropshare on both Macs.
  2. On the source Mac, go to Preferences > Connections > Add Connection and connect your cloud storage.

    The Preferences menu in Dropshare, a file-sharing app available on Setapp

  1. Drag the files to the Dropshare icon in the menu bar.
  2. Open Dropshare on the destination Mac, access the storage, and download the files.

You can also specify options like expiration dates and password protection to increase security.

Adding a new cloud storage connection in Dropshare, a file-sharing app available on Setapp

Read also:

Fix 6. Reinstall macOS

If you keep getting the “Migration Assistant logging out failed” message, try reinstalling macOS.

Note: Reinstalling macOS replaces corrupt system files and often fixes this error, but treat it as a last resort.

Follow these steps:

  1. Back up your Mac. Use Time Machine or Get Backup Pro, my favorite tool, which allows me to back up selected files.

    The main interface of Get Backup Pro, a backup app available on Setapp

  2. Shut down your Mac by choosing Apple menu > Shut Down.
  3. Enter macOS Recovery:
    • On an Apple silicon Mac, press and hold the power button until startup options appear, then release it. Choose Options > Continue.
    • On an Intel Mac, turn it on and immediately press and hold Command + R.
  4. Choose Reinstall macOS, then click Continue.
  5. Follow the on-screen instructions.

Do not turn off your Mac or close its lid until the reinstallation finishes. Then start your Mac and try the transfer again. See Apple’s instructions for using macOS Recovery if the startup options don’t appear.

Fix 7. Start your Mac in recovery mode

Recovery mode can help when Migration Assistant isn’t connecting. It gives you access to Disk Utility and other troubleshooting tools.

Here's how to get into recovery mode and run Disk Utility First Aid:

  1. Shut down your Mac.
  2. Start macOS Recovery:
    • On an Apple silicon Mac, press and hold the power button until startup options appear, then release it. Choose Options > Continue.
    • On an Intel Mac, turn it on and immediately press and hold Command + R until the Apple logo appears.
  3. Open Disk Utility.
  4. Choose your startup disk and run First Aid.
  5. Restart your Mac and try Migration Assistant again.

Recovery mode gives you access to Disk Utility, which can fix disk errors that block Migration Assistant. It also lets you reinstall macOS if system corruption is causing the problem.

Fix 8. Reset the System Management Controller

Resetting the System Management Controller can fix low-level hardware issues that cause Migration Assistant to freeze or lose connectivity.

Apple silicon Macs don’t have a user-resettable SMC. Restart the Mac, or shut it down and turn it back on. On an Intel Mac, follow the appropriate steps below.

For an Intel Mac laptop with the Apple T2 Security Chip:

  1. Shut down your Mac.
  2. Press and hold the left Control key, left Option key, and right Shift key for seven seconds. Your Mac may turn on.
  3. Keep holding those keys and press the power button. Hold all four keys together for seven seconds, then release them.
  4. Wait a few seconds and press the power button to turn on your Mac.

For an Intel Mac laptop without the T2 chip:

  1. Shut down your Mac.
  2. Press and hold the left Shift, left Control, and left Option keys, then press and hold the power button.
  3. Hold all four keys together for 10 seconds, then release them.
  4. Press the power button to turn on your Mac.

For an Intel Mac Pro, iMac, or Mac mini:

  1. Shut down your Mac.
  2. Disconnect the power cord.
  3. Wait 15 seconds with the power cord unplugged.
  4. Reconnect the power cord.
  5. Wait five seconds, then press the power button.

Apple’s guide explains how to reset the SMC on different Intel Mac models. After resetting it, try Migration Assistant again.

Fix 9. Migrate from a Time Machine backup

If a direct Mac-to-Mac transfer fails, Migration Assistant can migrate your data from a Time Machine backup. You need an external disk containing a recent backup of everything on your old Mac.

Follow these steps to start the migration from a Time Machine backup:

  1. Connect the Time Machine backup disk to your new Mac.
  2. Open Migration Assistant from the Applications > Utilities folder.
  3. Select From a Mac, Time Machine backup, or startup disk, then click Continue.
  4. Select your Time Machine backup and click Continue.
  5. Choose the backup date and the information you want to transfer.
  6. Click Continue to start the migration.

The migration can take several hours, depending on the connection speed and amount of data.

If you're looking for an alternative to Time Machine, I'd like to suggest Get Backup Pro. I first tried it when I needed to back up a few of my apps and folders that were vital to me (while all other content was not).

Get Backup Pro offers bootable clones for system restoration, automated backup scheduling, and file synchronization across devices. It also supports encrypted backups.

Using Get Backup Pro is straightforward. Open the app, choose a file backup, full system clone, or sync task, and select a destination. Then start the backup. If you want to give it a try, Get Backup Pro is available on Setapp. You can try it free for 7 days alongside the other Setapp apps mentioned in this article.

Migration Assistant vs. Time Machine

There is one key difference: Migration Assistant transfers information, while Time Machine stores backups.

Time Machine makes incremental backups of your files, apps, and account data. You can use it to restore individual files or recover an earlier version.

Migration Assistant can use another Mac, a Time Machine backup, or a startup disk as its transfer source. To migrate user accounts, apps, and settings from a Time Machine backup, use Migration Assistant rather than restoring files individually.

They serve different purposes, but they work well together when a direct Mac-to-Mac transfer fails.

Migration Assistant not working? Solved

If Migration Assistant fails, start by updating both Macs and checking the connection. You can then disable the firewall temporarily, run Apple Diagnostics, use macOS Recovery, or reset the SMC on an Intel Mac. A Time Machine backup is often the simplest fallback.

For manual transfers, Dropshare can move files through your cloud storage. Get Backup Pro helps create a backup before migration, while CleanMyMac can scan the source Mac before you move its data.

You'll find all three on Setapp, a single subscription for 300+ Mac apps. Start a free 7-day trial and put them to work on your next migration.

FAQ

What is Migration Assistant?

Migration Assistant is a utility included with macOS. It transfers user accounts, apps, documents, and settings from another Mac, a Time Machine backup, a startup disk, or a Windows PC.

What should I do if Migration Assistant isn’t working?

Check that both Macs run the latest supported macOS version. Make sure Wi-Fi is turned on, and both Macs are near each other — if either Mac is running OS X El Capitan or earlier, also connect both to the same Wi-Fi network. Restart them, disable VPN and firewall software temporarily, and confirm the destination has enough storage. If the problem continues, run Disk Utility First Aid or migrate from a Time Machine backup. Contact Apple Support if Migration Assistant still fails.

How long does Migration Assistant take?

Migration Assistant can take a few minutes or several hours. The total time depends on the amount of data and whether you use Wi-Fi, Ethernet, or Thunderbolt. It may take several minutes to prepare before the progress bar moves. Keep both Macs connected to power until the transfer finishes.

Does Migration Assistant transfer everything to my new Mac?

Migration Assistant transfers most apps, user accounts, documents, and settings. It may exclude incompatible apps, some system files, and security-related information. You might need to sign back into services or reactivate licensed software after the migration.

How do I transfer a Mac without Migration Assistant?

You can restore individual files with Time Machine, copy them to an external drive, or use cloud storage. Get Backup Pro can create file backups or clones, while Dropshare helps move selected files through connected cloud storage.

Why won’t Windows Migration Assistant open?

Download the Windows Migration Assistant version that matches the macOS version on your new Mac. Install available Windows updates, restart the PC, and temporarily pause antivirus or firewall software. If it still won’t open, uninstall the utility and download a fresh copy using Apple’s Windows migration instructions.

How do I start Migration Assistant?

Open Applications > Utilities > Migration Assistant, then click Continue. You can also press Command + Space, type “Migration Assistant,” and press Return. During initial Mac setup, Setup Assistant can start the same migration process automatically.

300+ apps for all your daily tasks.

Sign up to Setapp and try them for free.

Security-tested