Key Takeaways
  • Best GIF maker for most people: Gifox records your screen straight to GIF and converts existing videos, with full control over file size and quick access from your menu bar.
  • Best for screen recording: CleanShot X captures your screen as a GIF and gives you a shareable link right away. Choose Capto if you want to trim and annotate the recording first.
  • Best free converter: Gifski turns videos into GIFs at up to 50 FPS, with controls for size, quality, and looping. It doesn’t record your screen.
  • Keep file size small: Trim the clip, drop to 10–15 FPS, and resize to about 480 pixels wide. Then compress the result with Compresto or Squash.
  • Try the Setapp apps together: Gifox, CleanShot X, Capto, Permute, and more of the tools in this guide come in one Setapp Membership. Try them free for 7 days.

I make most of our team’s internal GIF memes, so I’ve tested dozens of GIF makers for Mac. My top pick is Gifox, which records your screen and converts it to a GIF. CleanShot X is great for recording and sharing, and Gifski is the best free MP4-to-GIF converter. Below, I compare pros, cons, and pricing for each app.

First, here’s a quick comparison of each GIF maker by type, frame rate and quality, editing tools, and price, so you can pick the right one for your source. Detailed descriptions follow below:

App Type Max FPS/qualityEditing Price 
Gifox Recorder, converterAdjustable frame rate, palette, and ditheringTrim, crop, split, duplicateFrom $14.99 USD/mo with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days
CleanShot XRecorderGIF or video; video recording supports 480p–4KTrim, annotate, quick sharingFrom $14.99 USD/mo with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days
Capto Recorder, editorMultiple recording frame rates; adjustable export qualityTrim, cut, annotations, textFrom $14.99 USD/mo with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days
Dropshare Recorder, sharingGIF or 24/60 FPS videoCapture, annotate, uploadFrom $14.99 USD/mo with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days
Permute ConverterDepends on source file and export settingsBasic conversion and preset controlsFrom $14.99 USD/mo with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days
Gifski ConverterUp to 50 FPSCrop, resize, set speed and qualityFree 
Pulltube Downloader, trimmerDepends on source videoTrim before savingFrom $14.99 USD/mo with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days
SnapMotionFrame extractorDepends on source videoSelect and export frames; make GIFs from imagesFrom $14.99 USD/mo with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days

Setapp is a subscription platform offering 300+ macOS, iOS, and web apps for a flat monthly fee.

What are the best GIF creation tools?

On the one hand, you don't need much from your animated GIF maker on Mac. You want to open a video, convert it into a GIF, and output it to a platform of your choice. However, the user experience of this simple process can vary dramatically depending on the tool you use.

That's why I've tested dozens of apps and chosen the best GIF recorder options for Mac, comparing the results below.

Best screen-to-GIF recorders

These apps record what happens on your Mac screen. They’re a good fit for tutorials, product demos, bug reports, and short reactions. Choose the capture area before you start if you only want to show one window or interaction.

Gifox: The fastest GIF maker 

I'll start with the most robust, precision-oriented, and thus the best GIF app out there (in my opinion) — Gifox. It's a sleek and intuitive GIF screen recorder for Mac that helps you easily create and share animated instructions, micro-screencasts, demos, and workflows as GIFs.

Beyond standard editing features, Gifox lets you select pixel-perfect custom regions or capture GIFs from specific windows. Access the app from your Mac menu bar, record GIFs exactly how you want, and edit your creations by cropping, resizing, adjusting color balance, and more, using hotkeys for speed and fine-grained control. 

Here's how to turn any video into a GIF with Gifox:

  1. Install and launch Gifox.
  2. Click Upload (arrow-shaped button) and choose the video you'd like to use for your GIF.
  3. Wait for Gifox to automatically turn your video into a GIF.

Pros:

  • Absolute control over output file size
  • Screen selection and recording tools
  • Instant cloud-sharing options
  • Modern UI

Cons:

  • The trial version creates watermarked videos

Technical details:

  • Price: From $14.99 USD/mo + tax with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days
  • Supported systems: macOS
  • URL: https://setapp.com/apps/gifox
  • Features: Quick access through your menu bar, advanced compression options, hotkey support
  • Availability: Setapp, Gifox

CleanShot X: All-around GIF maker and screen recorder

Mac users looking for the best GIF maker for flawless screen captures should try CleanShot X.

CleanShot X is a powerful GIF recorder for Mac with an extensive feature set that helps you quickly capture your Mac's screen without desktop icons, record and trim video, annotate, save screenshots to a dedicated cloud, and more.

To use CleanShot X as a GIF screen recorder, simply choose Record Screen in the app and proceed to record your screen as a GIF right away, so you don't have to convert anything later. Open the Quick Access Overlay panel from the pop-up window for a convenient editing toolkit. Once you finish recording and editing your GIF, CleanShot X will provide you with a shareable link to it right away.

With an extensive list of practical tools, CleanShot X can easily replace a few single-feature programs you might use for different tasks.

Pros:

  • Instant cloud sharing
  • Disabling notifications and hiding icons
  • Screenshot annotation tools
  • Text recognition capabilities

Cons:

  • Not free unless used with Setapp

Technical details:

  • Price: From $14.99 USD/mo + tax with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days
  • Supported systems: macOS
  • URL: https://setapp.com/apps/cleanshot
  • Features: Cloud sharing, audio and webcam recording, annotation, hiding icons and notifications
  • Availability: Setapp, CleanShot X

Capto: Best for editing recordings before export

Need a GIF that feels polished without bouncing between apps? Capto records your Mac screen, then brings the footage into its built-in editor. Trim away pauses to keep the action moving. Add a callout when a step needs extra explanation. Export the finished recording as a GIF for a quick demo, or keep it as video when you need more detail. 

The interface of Capto, a screen capture and video editing app available on Setapp

Pros:

  • Combines screen recording and editing
  • Exports short clips as GIFs

Cons:

  • Fewer GIF-specific controls than a dedicated recorder

Technical details:

  • Price: From $14.99 USD/mo + tax with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days
  • Supported systems: macOS
  • URL: https://setapp.com/apps/capto
  • Features: Screen recording, trimming, annotations, GIF and video export
  • Availability: Setapp

Dropshare: Best for recording and sharing in one step

Need to send a screen demo without attaching a bulky file? Dropshare records part or all of your screen as a GIF, then uploads it through a storage service you connect. A shareable link is ready for your teammate. Set up a shortcut to start captures faster. You can also annotate screenshots before sharing. For faster, higher-quality GIF conversion, you may need FFmpeg.

Sharing a file via the menu bar in Dropshare, a file-sharing utility available on Setapp

Pros:

  • Records screen captures as GIFs or video
  • Uploads files and creates shareable links

Cons:

  • Requires a configured storage connection
  • GIF recording may require FFmpeg

Technical details:

  • Price: From $14.99 USD/mo + tax with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days, or from $39.00 USD as a standalone app 
  • Supported systems: macOS
  • URL: https://setapp.com/apps/dropshare
  • Features: Screen recording, GIF export, annotations, uploads, share links
  • Availability: Setapp

Best video-to-GIF converters

Already have an MP4 or MOV? A converter can turn it into a GIF without recording your screen. For a private or large video, a Mac app that processes the file locally can also save you from uploading it to an online service.

Permute: Best for converting many media formats

Permute converts saved videos to GIF by adding a clip and choosing GIF Animation. It also converts image and audio formats. The app is useful when you need one tool for several media conversions, but it doesn’t provide a timeline editor for precise clip edits. Trim the clip first if you need to isolate a specific moment.

The interface of Permute, a GIF maker app available on Setapp

Pros:

  • Converts video, image, and audio formats
  • Simple GIF conversion workflow

Cons:

  • No detailed timeline editing

Technical details:

  • Price: From $14.99 USD/mo + tax with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days, or from $4.99 USD/year as a standalone app
  • Supported systems: macOS
  • URL: https://setapp.com/apps/permute 
  • Features: Video-to-GIF and media format conversion
  • Availability: Setapp

Gifski: Best free MP4-to-GIF converter

Gifski is a free, open-source Mac app for converting videos into GIFs. Add a video, choose a section, and adjust the output settings. You can change the dimensions, frame rate, speed, quality, and loop settings. Gifski supports up to 50 FPS, but it doesn’t record your screen.

Source: https://gif.ski/

Pros:

  • Free and open source
  • Supports up to 50 FPS
  • Offers control over size and quality

Cons:

  • Converts video but doesn’t record your screen
  • No timeline editor for detailed editing

Technical details:

  • Price: Free
  • Supported systems: macOS
  • URL: https://gif.ski
  • Features: Video-to-GIF conversion, frame rate and quality settings, resizing, cropping, looping
  • Availability: Mac App Store, direct download

Ezgif: A simple web-based GIF maker

Ezgif is another simple, effective web-based GIF creator that works well for making and editing straightforward GIFs. Just like GIPHY, Ezgif has various basic edit options but doesn't offer a library of free GIFs to choose from.

You don't need to download any apps or extensions to use Ezgif, making it a great one-time solution if you know you won't need to output GIFs regularly. Ezgif has a straightforward interface, though some may find it a little outdated. Still, this online tool is easy to navigate, so you won't waste time searching for the key features.

Beyond standard editing tools, Ezgif lets you customize and enhance your GIF with filters, effects, and text overlays. One drawback of this animated GIF maker is that it supports only a few video file formats, which can be a hassle if your format isn't on the list.

Pros:

  • Easy to use
  • Various customization options
  • Supports all standard image formats

Cons:

  • Ads
  • Outdated UI
  • Only supports a few video file formats

Technical details:

  • Price: Free
  • Supported systems: macOS and Windows
  • URL: https://ezgif.com 
  • Features: Convert videos to GIFs, add text, resize and crop images
  • Availability: Online

Best download-and-convert video tools

A downloader doesn’t usually make the GIF itself. It gets a video onto your Mac, where you can trim and convert it with another app. Only download content you have permission to use and that the source platform allows you to save.

Pulltube: Best for downloading and trimming a clip

Found the perfect moment in an online video? Pulltube can save a clip from many services and lets you trim it before downloading, so you don’t have to keep the whole file. Then open the saved segment in a GIF converter such as Permute. Pulltube is a handy first step when your source isn’t already on your Mac, though it doesn’t create GIFs itself.

Downloading a video on Pulltube, a video downloader app for Mac available on Setapp

Pros:

  • Downloads videos from many online services
  • Trims clips before saving

Cons:

  • Needs a separate app to convert video to GIF
  • Downloads depend on the source site

Technical details:

  • Price: From $14.99 USD/mo + tax with Setapp Membership, free for 7 days, or from $19.99 USD as a standalone app  
  • Supported systems: macOS
  • URL: https://setapp.com/apps/pulltube 
  • Features: Video downloads, trimming, audio extraction
  • Availability: Setapp 

Best tools to create GIFs from photos or video frames

Sometimes you want to build an animation from selected still images rather than convert an entire clip. In that case, extract frames from a video or upload images to an online GIF creator.

SnapMotion: Best for extracting frames

SnapMotion extracts still images from video, including high-resolution footage. Choose a frame to save or capture multiple frames in batches. You can rotate or flip videos before capturing. SnapMotion can also combine images into a GIF or MP4.

The interface of SnapMotion, a frame capture app available on Setapp

Pros:

  • Captures frames from high-resolution video
  • Supports batch extraction
  • Creates GIFs and MP4s from images

Cons:

  • Takes more steps than converting a whole video directly
  • Focuses on frame extraction rather than detailed GIF editing

Technical details:

  • Price: From $14.99 USD/mo + tax with Setapp Membership or from $5.39 USD/year as a standalone app, free for 7 days 
  • Supported systems: macOS
  • URL: https://setapp.com/apps/snapmotion 
  • Features: Frame extraction, batch capture, rotate and flip, GIF and MP4 creation
  • Availability: Setapp

GIPHY: Online GIF-making favorite

Most users know GIPHY as the go-to search engine for animated images, but beyond its seemingly endless collection from around the world, it also offers GIF-making software. Users who know about the GIPHY Create feature often deem this free online tool the best GIF maker. And it's not for nothing.

GIPHY's GIF creator tools are very straightforward. You just have to paste a source URL or upload a video to the platform, then choose the bit to create your GIF from. Next, you can add stickers, captions, and filters. GIPHY also offers a variety of integrations with popular social media sites and messaging apps, making it more convenient to share your GIFs.

Because GIPHY is an online tool, you need a stable internet connection for smooth video uploads and downloads.

Pros:

  • Free GIF library
  • Variety of basic editing options
  • Easy social media sharing and smartphone upload integration

Cons:

  • Not all file formats are supported
  • Many URLs won't upload
  • Some content is inappropriate

Technical details:

  • Price: Free
  • Supported systems: macOS and Windows
  • URL: https://giphy.com 
  • Features: Make GIFs from web video links, add captions, and create stickers
  • Availability: Online

What replaced GIF Brewery on Mac?

GIF Brewery is no longer available to new users through the Mac App Store. Choose a replacement based on the part of its workflow you need:

  • For recording your screen: Gifox offers region and window capture plus GIF-focused controls. CleanShot X is a good alternative if you also want screenshots and shareable links.
  • For converting MP4 or MOV files: Gifski is free and lets you adjust frame rate and quality. Permute is a convenient option if you already use Setapp.
  • For editing and annotations: Capto combines recording, trimming, and annotations; Ezgif can add text in a browser.
  • For quick online sharing: GIPHY’s GIF Maker can add captions and stickers before you share.

How to keep GIF file size small

GIFs can become large because they store many frames as a sequence of images. A few adjustments before and after conversion can make a file easier to upload or send:

  • Use only the frames you need: Trim the clip to the shortest moment that still explains the action.
  • Lower the frame rate: A lower FPS means fewer frames to store. For a simple screen demo, test around 10–15 FPS first; use more only if movement looks choppy.
  • Reduce the dimensions: Resize the GIF to the width it will appear at. A 480-pixel-wide animation is often enough for a small preview or message.
  • Limit colors when the image allows it: GIF supports up to 256 colors per frame. Flat interface recordings often tolerate a smaller palette better than colorful footage.
  • Compress the export: Compresto and Squash can compress GIFs and other media. Both apps are available on Setapp. Compare the result at its intended display size, because aggressive compression can add visible artifacts. 

Always keep a copy of the original video or a high-quality export. You can then make a smaller GIF for sharing without losing the source.

For a deeper look at shrinking large source clips before you convert them, see this guide to video compression apps for Mac.

Choose a GIF maker for your source

The best GIF maker for Mac depends on where your clip starts. To record your screen, use Gifox or CleanShot X, and add Capto when you need to trim and annotate. To convert an existing video, Gifski is a free option, and Permute covers other formats too. 

You can try the Setapp apps in this guide alongside 300+ other Mac and iOS apps free for 7 days. Start your free trial today.

FAQ

What is the best GIF maker for Mac?

Gifox is a strong all-around choice for screen capture and video conversion. Choose CleanShot X for screenshots and sharing, or Gifski for free MP4 conversion.

How do I record my screen as a GIF on Mac?

Choose a recorder such as Gifox, CleanShot X, Capto, or Dropshare; select the screen, a window, or an area; then record, trim, and export as GIF. If it saves video, convert the file with Gifski or Permute.

What replaced GIF Brewery on Mac?

There isn’t one direct replacement. Use Gifox or CleanShot X to record, Gifski or Permute to convert, and Capto to edit and annotate.

What’s the best MP4-to-GIF converter for Mac?

Gifski is a strong free choice, with controls for frame rate, quality, dimensions, and looping. Permute also converts audio, images, and video.

Does macOS have a built-in GIF maker?

No. There’s no dedicated GIF maker for macOS. Record video with the system tools, then convert it with Gifski or Permute, or use Gifox or CleanShot X to record directly to GIF.

300+ apps for all your daily tasks.

Sign up to Setapp and try them for free.

Security-tested